Welcome Guest ( Log In | Register )

 

Hornby Rebuilt class 7P “Royal Scot” 4-6-0 46140

“The King’s Royal Rifle Corps”

Review by David Blythman


The Prototype

The Original

By 1926 it had become painfully clear to the LMS that it needed a more powerful locomotive to replace the doubled headed regime which was then hauling the premier London – Glasgow expresses. As the LNER had done the year before, the LMS arranged to borrow a Castle class locomotive from the GWR and once again the Castle proved a more than competent performer. This settled the design as a 4-6-0. The LMS had hoped to gain access to working drawings for the Castle but the GWR did not oblige. The company did get a set of drawings for the SR’s Lord Nelson but it seems little use was made of them. Such was the rush to get the locomotives into service that 50 were ordered from North British straight from the drawing boards at Derby.

These 50 locomotives were built by North British at their Queen’s Park and Hyde Park works. The first was delivered in July 1927 and all were in service by the end of the year. Despite some teething problems a further 20 were built at Derby in 1930.

The Scots remained in the front line of LMS passenger duties until Stanier’s new pacifics came on line.

The Rebuild

Although the Scots received the new taper boilers as the original boilers fell due for renewal from the early 1940s onwards, it is clear from company documents that Stanier had a rebuild in mind as early as 1934. The original locomotive was too heavy for large parts of the LMS network including the Midland Division. There was a tendency for coal consumption to rise sharply between overhauls because the pistons had only one ring to seal them in the cylinders. As these wore in service, a large part of the steam went straight past doing no work. The smoke box was difficult to clean due to its design, resulting in an excessive loss of “in service” time.

Despite recognising the need for an improvement, this project was less pressing than the development of the new pacifics and the smaller 5XP (Jubilee) class locomotives. That is not to say that nothing was done. The ill fated high pressure locomotive ‘Fury’ was fitted with a large taper boiler (classified as type 2), renamed “British Legion” and proved a useful, if ultimately unique engine.

In 1942 two Jubilees, 5735 and 5736 were fitted with a slightly modified version (type 2A) of the taper boiler fitted to “British Legion”, modified cylinders and valves, better bogie control and numerous other refinements. Not only did these two up rated locomotives outperform their peers, they outperformed the original Scots as well. The authorisation to rebuild all of the Scots swiftly followed and the rebuilding process began in 1943 and continued until the last of the class went through the works in January 1955. The rebuild was every bit as extensive as that for 5735 and 5736 with little more than the cab remaining of the original locomotive.

The Tender

When originally built, the Scots were paired with 3,500 gallon Fowler tenders. During 1932 coal rails were added to increase capacity but from 1936 the tenders were replaced by the new Stanier 4,000 gallon, 9 ton high sided design. These were taken as a straight swap from Jubilees but unlike the Jubilees, the Scots were generally paired with a single tender for life.

Vital Statistics (Rebuilt)
Weight: Locomotive 83 tons (~83000kg)
Pressure: 250psi Superheated
Driving Wheels: 6’ 9”
Cylinders: 3
Valve gear: Walschaerts
Tractive Effort: 33,150

Performance

Two rebuilt Scots were selected for the BR Interchange Trial of 1948 in which they turned in remarkable performances in the express category along side Coronation, A4, Merchant Navy and GW King locomotives. Such was the success of the rebuild components, the Scots outperformed the larger Kings much to the chagrin of the GWR. The balance of power tipped back in the Kings’ favour when they were later fitted with double chimneys.

One of the Scots’ weak points was their rough riding particularly when coming up to a major overhaul. When a Scot due for a service encountered a below par stretch of track it was not unknown for the footplate crew to grab hold of something solid to steady themselves against the bucking ride.

A few Scots broke the 100mph mark though not as many or as frequently as the Kings.

Areas of operation

The rebuilding of the Scots allowed them to operate over a wider part of the LMS. They were regularly rostered on the following ‘named’ trains – Thames-Clyde Express; The Waverley; The Ulster Express; The Irish Mail; The Merseyside Express; The Lakes Express. These trains were worked out of either Euston or St. Pancras. Photos also show Scots at the head of Liverpool – Newcastle workings, so trips to the ECML were not unknown.

Like many other steam locomotives, the Scots were displaced north westwards by the advent of diesels in the late 1950s. In the latter days of steam when ‘live’ steamers could turn up almost anywhere, 46141 was photographed on Eastleigh shed in February 1963.

All major servicing work was carried out at Crewe.

Withdrawal

The Scots were withdrawn from service between October 1962 and January 1966.

Preservation

Two members of the class have been preserved – 6100 “Royal Scot” and 46115 “Scots Guardsman”. They have both been in running order but are currently receiving major overhauls. “Royal Scot” is owned by Bressingham Steam Museum. It is currently being worked on at the London Mainline Steam Group’s Southall works. 46115 is privately owned and is believed to be at Carnforth.

The Model

Hornby has produced n models of the Royal Scot class in this first release
R2628 46102 “Black Watch” BR green; early crest; pristine condition
R2629 46140 “The King’s Royal Rifle Corps” BR green; early crest; weathered condition
R2630 46146 “The Rifle Brigade” BR green; late crest; pristine condition
R2631 6133 “The Green Howards” LMS 1946 Black; red and straw lining

Each model is available as DCC Ready or DCC fitted.

This review is of R2629 “The King’s Royal Rifle Corps” in DCC Ready form.

Opening the box

The locomotive comes in one of Hornby’s sleeved boxes where the sleeve shows the particular model on the front with historical information relevant to that model on the back. The blue “DCC Ready” flash is also printed on the sleeve.

Inside the sleeve is a standard model railway box enclosing a two part polystyrene casing. The two halves of this casing are held together at each end by clear plastic bands. These are easily removed to allow the top half of the casing to be removed. The tender can now be lifted out of the box. The locomotive is still held fast by a pair of L shaped brackets which have been screwed to the base of the wheel keeper plate. The long part of the L is a press fit into the bottom half of the polystyrene casing. A little gentle upward pressure is all that is required to ease the locomotive away. The next task is to loosen the keeper plate screws to free the L plates. Until these are removed, the locomotive cannot be placed on its wheels.

Compared to other locomotive packing methods, removing the model is particularly easy with this design.

Detail parts

The add on parts consist of locomotive brake rigging; tender brake rigging; NEM coupler for the front bogie; front footsteps; front vacuum pipe; dummy screw link coupling; drain cocks

First sight

The overall impression is of a nice understated model. This is partly because 46140 is the variat with a “weathered” finish. The lower part of the model has been lightly sprayed with a dusty colour. The chief beneficiary appears to be the valve gear. The lining is particularly neat and unobtrusive.

Having pored over many photographs prior to obtaining this model, there were few surprises when I looked at it for the first time out of the box. The usual RTR over large gap between locomotive and tender is present though with the folded cab doors it is not as obtrusive as it could be. The height disparity between the cab footsteps and the tender footsteps is also present on the prototype.

There is no mould line along the centre of the boiler. Instead there are two faint lines discernible about 6 mm either side of the centre line. The holes in the brake rod actuators are conspicuous for some reason but there’s brake rigging in the detail parts bag to fill those.

The front end looks particularly bare. The front steps and cylinder drain cocks are both optional and intended for those with the wider curves which don’t force the leading bogie so far from under the chassis.

On the plus side, there is plenty of detail on the footplate. My personal favourite is the box with multiple copper coloured pipes coming out of it.

How does it run?

For many people this is the most important attribute of the model – does it run well?

Trackwork

Hornby state that you need a minimum of radius 2 curves to run this model. If you fit the front steps and drain cocks the minimum radius goes up to 25” which is more than many people have room for.

My layout is a mixture of Peco streamline code 100 and code 75 with electrofrog points, slips and crossings. There were no problems with derailments and none of my curves posed a problem for the steps or cylinder drain cocks.

Electrical connections

Like all Hornby’s recent steam models, 46140 has electrical pickups on all six driving wheels and all six tender wheels as well. The additional tender pickups turned out to be vital when I was programming the DCC decoder on the programming track. There was the occasional hesitation at very low speed indicating some “misses” despite six points of contact down both sides. I don’t know if this is attributable to the model or to the decoder. A Hornby A4 which has pickup on 6 driving wheels and 8 tender wheels and a Lenz gold decoder never falters.

Top speed

With those large 6’ 9” drivers and standard Hornby gearing, the top speed the model can achieve is far in excess of the prototype.

Low speed

Low speed performance is excellent provided the decoder is getting power from the track. On my rolling road, the motor would turn without pause at speed step 1 of 128. At this speed, the movement of the driving wheels is almost imperceptible.

Haulage

The model performs well on the level and pulled an 11 coach train including 4 Hornby illuminated Pullmans with ease.

On a 1:50 gradient, there was a little wheel slip when the last Hornby Gresley of six was on the slope but the model was able to continue. It was not able to start the train while on the gradient. There was no wheel slip, just a worrying buzzing noise suggesting that the motor worm wheel was not engaging. The limit would appear to be about 5 coaches for 1:50 and less for anything steeper than that.

Fitting the detail parts

The detail parts are fairly easy to fit. I would advise fitting the locomotive brake rigging starting from the cab end. The front steps have to be glued in place. Everything else is a secure push fit. This job is best done after DCC conversion.

DCC

In DCC Ready models, the 8 pin NEM socket is located at the front of the boiler just behind the smokebox. (An important note for Seuthe customers. The smokebox is entirely enclosed. A lot of surgery is required if you are going to fit a smoke unit). As I have now converted to DCC, details of how I fitted a decoder are included at the end of the review.

Summary of operating characteristics

  • Recommended radius 2 or larger

  • Sealed for life can motor

  • Current pick up from all six driving wheels and all six tender wheels

  • Loco / tender connection by standard Hornby pin and hole with two circuit link

  • DCC 8 pin socket in boiler

  • No load current consumption (measured): Forwards:160 mA; Reverse: 160 mA; Stall Current ~1 Amp.

  • Current consumption (Manufacturer): 200 mA to 400 mA.

Other features

  • Weight:425 grammes

  • Couplings: Front – NEM 362 coupler mount. Tender: Press fit to peg.

Third party add ons

If the standard Hornby detail parts such as safety valves and whistle are not to your liking, companies such as Brassmasters make turned parts which may suit you better.
Alternative wheels can be had from Markits.

Kadee couplings

This is the biggest disappointment for me on this model. The tender coupling is a “press fit” to peg design, not the NEM 362 that I have become used to on Hornby’s A3 and A4 pacific tenders. Conversion is not going to be a simple job.

Sound

Hornby does not yet produce any models with steam sound and there are no British three cylinder steam sounds on the after market either. Should such a product appear, the tender is the obvious home for a sound decoder and loud speaker. There appears to be enough room for one if the weight is relocated and a judicious amount of surgery is carried out on the coal bunker.

The speaker in this photo is a DCC Supplies bass reflex model. These are larger than the usual oval speakers.

How does it measure up to the prototype?

General appearance

I have never seen “the real thing” so my impressions are based on a lot of black and white photographs, most of which have been taken from ground level. The model certainly ticks all the right boxes for Royal Scot features – distinctive smoke deflectors, double chimney, taper boiler, large driving wheels, running plate mounted sandboxes, footsteps below the smoke box, Stanier high sided tender.

By coincidence (or else the Hornby designers also own the book) there is a double page photo of 46140 “in perfect nick” in “The book of the Royal Scots”. This is large enough to allow me identify the various parts on the left side of the locomotive. As far as I can tell, apart from the leading wheel sanding pipe, everything is present and correct. I haven’t counted the rivets but they look right. Looking at the name plate you might think that the regimental badge is missing but the photo of 46140 shows that there was no badge. Each of the driving wheels has a different arrangement of balance weights.

I have a particular liking for outside valve gear. All the major components have been modelled by Hornby and there is very little “slop” evident as it runs at low speed. The coupling rods are of the fluted type which is correct for the period represented.

Detail

There is a wealth of detail on this model. My particular favourite are the boxes and associated copper coloured pipe work at the forward end of the running plate.

The shed plate on the front is 9A – Longsight (Manchester). 46140 was allocated to this shed from June 1954 to September 1959.

The cab is yet another highly detailed Hornby production and yet again I have to rely on an enlarged photo to take in all that is present. The dials do have faces complete with numbers and a needle indication. The roof vent can be opened and closed.

The tender has a removable coal load which reveals the shaped bunker underneath. The rear of the tender carries two plates. One gives the water capacity – 4000 gallons; the other is the build plate – LMS 9341. I can’t make out the year. 46140 was paired with tender 9341 in May 1936 and retained it for the rest of its working life.

Other models

Airfix made a model of 46100 Royal Scot in the late 1970s. In terms of detail and performance it was a considerable improvement on other British outline models available at the time. Even now it is still a reasonable looking model. For some, the chimney shape of the Airfix is better than the Hornby. I don’t have any drawings for the chimney so I can’t say which is correct. Here’s a photo of the two models head.

 

Conclusion

This is another fine model from Hornby. It captures the essence of the prototype well. It has a wealth of detail above and below the running plate and is a good runner. The DCC installation is a tight fit but if you don’t want advanced decoder ‘bells and whistles’, Hornby also have DCC fitted versions available; just add an X and a few more pounds. I am in a minority who fit Kadee couplings to their models, so my disappointment at the tender coupler mounting will not be shared by many. I look forward to other members of the class being produced in the years to come. A Holbeck based Scot would soon find a home on my layout.

Fitting a decoder

First the front bogie has to be removed

to gain access to the screw under the smoke box which secures the boiler to the chassis

Once the screw has been removed, the chassis can be separated from the body by pulling gently down on the cylinders. The body is a tight fit and with all that delicate detail is a slightly stressed moment. The chassis has to clear the front of the footplate before it can be drawn forward to release the chassis lugs from the backplate.

Once the body and chassis have been separated you see that there is not a lot of space for a decoder. A long thin rectangle is more likely to fit than a thin square.

Neil Wood managed to a fit a Lenz Gold to his Scot. I don’t know how he found the space. I opted for a Zimo MX620R which is smaller.

As you can see, the MX620 is not as long as the splasher. The chassis completely fills the gap in the bottom of the boiler so decoder and its wiring have to in the space at the boiler sides and just in front of the decoder socket.

At this stage you should check that the model runs smoothly. If it doesn’t run well on DC, DCC isn’t going to make it any better. Now plug in the decoder and check that everything is working. This took me some time as I was get errors writing CV values. The problem only went away when I attached the tender. It is important that you do this now because once you get the body back on, you will not want to repeat the process. Be very careful when you are testing the decoder at this stage that none of the live parts come into contact with anything conductive and short out. If that happens, the decoder will probably be toast. When you are happy with the decoder operation, it’s time to secure the decoder to the body and put it all back together again.

The MX620R comes with a sticky pad which you can use to secure it to the inside of the boiler like this:

The lead is just long enough to allow the body to lie on its back alongside the chassis while you plug in the decoder. Now comes the tricky bit. There are several things you must watch for at all times:

  • The leads to the tender drawbar need to go inside the injector pipework.

  • The leads to the decoder must not get trapped between the body and the chassis.

  • There are tiny little brackets on the valve gear which slop about a lot from side to side. They are supposed to go behind a circular bracket under the running plate but they are more likely to flop sideways and go the wrong side of this bracket. They are not very strong and will get bent if you don’t notice in time.


The body should drop into place without too much pressure. If you are having to press very hard, then something has got trapped. If it’s not a decoder wire, it’s probably one of those valve gear brackets.

Links and References

The book of the Royal Scots. A British Railways Illustrated Special. Published by Irwell Press. ISBN 1-871608-99-6

Great railway photographs by Eric Treacy. Compiled by G. Freeman Allen. ISBN 0 7537 0872 8

Gresley and Stanier – A Centenary Tribute. John Bellwood and David Jenkinson. HMSO ISBN 0 11 290253 7

The British 4-6-0 John F Clay. ISBN 450 03239 6.

British Railways Locomotives – 1955. Chris Banks. Published by OPC. ISBN 0 86093 560 4.

British Railways Locomotives & Locoshed Book 1959. Published by Ian Allen ISBN 0 7110 0726 8

http://www.londonsteam.org.uk/6100.html
 

 

- October 2007

 

 

 

RSS    Lo-Fi Version Time is now: 1st June 2020 - 09:51