Model Railway Forum banner
1 - 3 of 42 Posts

· Registered
Joined
·
5,598 Posts
It's a throw away item IMHO. All of you who clammered for factory fitted decoders, will be buying inferior products. I personally will not be buying any Bachmann product with a decoder fitted, until they change the specification. I demand four digit addressing, and as they won't be fitting such decoders, I'll fit my own.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
5,598 Posts
Poor logic, I buy a loco DCC ready with a decoder, I have to remove it, fit my own decoder, then sell on the Bachmann or Hornby badged Lenz decoder on for peanuts...........no way.

I want a quality decoder with 4 digit addressing, and a full range of CV's. What chance then for Bachmann loco's with sound. ? "great for trainsets but not for me in this format"

Yes Bachmann have improved there products, but were talking about a new range of products here.
As I said IMHO it's not the product I want, I would prefer to buy my own decoder and do my own thing. Ryan this applies to you as well, even if your learning DCC, which is really simple.
I'm also dismayed by talk that Hornby's DCC system will not support 4 Digit addressing or a full range of DCC functions.
The message to both manufactures is either do DCC properly or leave to the specialists in the field. Non standard DCC (IE does not fully conform to NMRA standards- such as they are) is condeming the purchasers to a tied arrangement, buy my loco's, buy my system. It sounds like a really poor decision, and ranks along side live steam.
We could be watching a wonderful opportunity missed by poor management decisions, and lack of long term vision, for short term gain.
I had in mind to buy a Hornby Elite just for my study shunting plank, but now I've decided it will be a Digitrax Zephur, just a few pennies more, but more verstile, more amps, and fitting in nicely with my existing Digitrax equipment. Proven, and NMRA compliant.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
5,598 Posts
QUOTE Ermm! Digitrax, isn't that going for the "tied arrangement"?

Sorry for the delayed reply we've been away

No as I have a large investment in Digitrax kit anyway. I'm very happy with my Digitrax kit and it's given me five years plus of trouble free running. So how large is large:
DCS100 command station
DB150 booster
DT400 x 4 hand controllers
UT4 x 2 hand controllers for visitors
UP5 x 7 Panel Sockets
2 x 5 amp transformers
BDL16 occupancy detector
and various other bit and bobs
so I'd say I have an investment in Digitrax and their kit.
 
1 - 3 of 42 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top