Just finished this and thought you might like to see it.
Comet Models excellent Ivatt 2 kit fitted with SWD LMS Mogul ESU sound chip in the boiler, ahead of the vertical motor with a DCC Supplies base-reflex speaker in the tender.Not the best filming in the world but I couldn't drive both at the same time! Link to vid should be here
When ordering this chip you can/should specify BR Whistle OR LMS ( Stanier) type hooter, which the Ivatts carried. Now it has dawned on me that this LMS chip has many possible 2 cyl. applications. Stanier/Fairburn/ Ivatt tanks, Ivatt Class 4 Mogul, and obviously Staniers' class 5/8, simply re-synched using CVs 57/58 to suit wheel diameter and achieve 4 beats per cycle. Interestingly, AFAIK, the only Stanier design not to use his distinctive hooter was his design Mogul, which used the Midland whistle, probably as a result of following the "Crabs" and Horwich practise.
The video really doesn't do justice to the beefiness of the sound from the tender fitted base/reflex speaker. That said, there's a part kit-built Black 5 on the bench with a sound chip from Howes which features a VERY impressive sequence of loose coupled wagon buffer-clash. This will have two 23mm speakers in the tender. A video of that will appear when it's complete.
Thanks for the extra info. I have a Bachmann class 2 and the reflex speaker. I just haven't got round to getting a sound chip yet.
QUOTE The video really doesn't do justice to the beefiness of the sound from the tender fitted base/reflex speaker
That's not the first time a comment like that has been made. Doug has said the same about the Deltic recording. I don't think it's the playback facility because the "Three deltic" clip he posted with the sound review had plenty of bass which got my sub woofer going. From that I conclude that the mike that comes standard on the video camera (or still) has weak low frequency response and misses the "beefiness" completely. Should we call these mikes "vegetarians"?
Here should be a couple of clips of the now complete aforementioned Black5, 45107, shunting a few Stanier brake vans around.
It's a detailed Hornby loco body, combined dome/top feed variant on a kit built chassis and kit built tender. I've used Howes chip in this and reckon the rod-clank and loose coupled wagon clash to be particularly effective.
I fitted 2x 23mm speakers in the tender, wired parallel and in phase and this has allowed a reduction in volume to a value of 30 and it's still plenty loud enough. The long crow of the hooter is allocated to F2 and Howes instructions say press once for on / once for off, using Dynamis, setting F2 to trigger means it blows whilst the button is pressed and I've had a lot of fun mixing this with the short pop, F3, allowing a bit of individual drivership. CV 57 needed a bit of tweaking to achieve 4 beats per cycle, I guess this chip is aimed at Hornbys RTR loco with a different motor/reduction to my chosen Mashima 16/24 mated to Comets' 50/1 'box.
Next project, 44709, again a Hornby loco body, Ivatt boilered variant this time, with Comets' LWB chassis and welded tender, this time with a single base-reflex speaker in the tender to allow a comparison to be made.
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could
be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Model Railway Forum
A forum community dedicated to Model train and railway owners and enthusiasts. Come join the discussion about collections, displays, models, styles, scales, motors, reviews, accessories, classifieds, and more!