Model Railway Forum banner
1 - 5 of 5 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
5,592 Posts
This is the review that appeared from this weeks Model Railroader's electronic news sheet.

Electronics Solutions Ulm's ECoS digital control system
Reviewed in the June 2007 issueTerry Thompson, editorPrint | Email | Contact Us April 20, 2007 With two built-in throttles, a long list of features, an LCD touch screen, and ample possibilities for expansion, Electronic Solutions Ulm's new ECoS digital control system is the most complete digital single-unit controller we've tested. Not only is it capable of sending commands in multiple formats (Digital Command Control [DCC], Märklin/Motorola, and Trix Selectrix), but its programming tools simplify the often-frustrating task of setting the configuration variables (CVs) of a decoder. It doesn't have the full set of capabilities of the new Märklin Systems, so locomotives with mfx decoders can't register themselves, though you can control them with the ECos. But beyond that there are few digital tasks it can't handle.

A Continental approach. The ECoS is a European-style system, intended for use as the main digital controller and workstation for a layout. The two throttles feature motor-driven speed control knobs with "below zero" reverse (stop the locomotive, then turn the throttle below the stop position to reverse the locomotive) and a small multifunction mushroom-shaped joystick that can be used to select locomotives and activate functions. If you select a locomotive that's in motion, the controller will advance the throttle to the proper step for a seamless acquisition.

In many ways the ECoS feels like a small, specialized PC workstation. This is a strength and a weakness, from the North American perspective. Operation and programming are simpler with the ECoS than with many DCC handhelds or base stations, both because the display gives you more information and because the powerful system makes tasks simpler. The drawback is that the system doesn't include a walkaround controller, and the ESU Mobile Control wireless throttle isn't licensed for use in the United States. You can add a controller from another firm.

In normal operation the LCD touch screen displays the locomotive name and icon, both of which you select, and a speedometer that reads in either speed steps or km/h. The 7" (diagonal) screen is angled 16 degrees up from horizontal and backlit in white. The monochrome screen is easy to read, though color would make it easier to distinguish different screens and tools.

The system comes with a 90VA outboard power supply; maximum track current is 4.0 amps. I measured the track voltage at 17.2V using an RRampMeter. (ESU has announced a multiprotocol ECoSBOOST digital booster for delivery later this year, and the system will also work with DCC boosters from other manufacturers.) It has several connections, including track power, programming track power, RJ45 Ethernet, 3 ECosLink plugs, S88 track occupancy, and ECoSniffer system input, which can accept the output signal from another independent digital system.
Main sockets include (left to right) Ethernet, ECoS Extend, ECoS Connect, and main/program track. Simplified programming. To enter the programming modes you press one of a group of icons across the top of the screen. Some are for system setup; others are for programming mobile and stationary decoders. Here also you have multiple choices. For example, you can select a CV and the value you want by pressing the up (+) or down (-) icons on the screen to select the CV number. You can also enter numbers directly from the keypad that appears on the screen. The system can even read the profiles of some, mainly ESU, decoders.

Operation. Despite the system's power, it's easy to get started. Adding a locomotive to the system can be done by simply entering its address and your preferred protocol, such as Motorola 28-step or DCC 128-step. The system will give it a name if you don't enter one. Then select that locomotive and you're off.

The eight function buttons are large and easy to use, but it took me some time to get used to the small joystick. You can also access up to 20 additional functions on the touch screen.

The system's capabilities for accessory operation are robust as well. The ECoS maintains a library of 25 accessory panels with up to 16 accessories each, such as signals or turnouts. You can also name routes that can be controlled manually or via the S88-format feedback bus, including eight two-station shuttle routes, each with deceleration intervals.

Auxiliary sockets include (left to right) inputs for power boosters, ECoSniffer, and a feedback bus. A few quirks. As you'd expect with a system this powerful, our sample had a few quirks. Occasionally a locomotive jumped from one speed step to another if I set the throttle at the border between two steps. I left the ECoS on and undisturbed for 24 hours; after that time the display was on but the system wouldn't issue commands.

I also had a few Motorola and mfx format decoders go into the digital equivalent of paralysis. While I wasn't able to reprogram them using the ECoS, they did revive when tested on a Märklin Central Station. It appears to be a reaction by some decoders to having multiple protocols on the same track, regardless of which multi-protocol system is in use.

An excellent performer. Overall, the system performed very well. I used it to operate locomotives with decoders in DCC, Märklin/Motorola, and mfx formats. The nearly endless expansion possibilities mean that an ECoS user is unlikely to outgrow the system. It's not quite my dream controller - I wish the throttles were pressure-sensitive levers and that adding a wireless throttle were simpler - but it's a powerful, intelligently engineered system. As such, it sets the standard for digital multiprotocol controller/workstations.

 

·
No Longer Active.
Joined
·
13,319 Posts
Nice report MMaD & thanks for posting it.

I have been thinking seriously about this beast but am wondering if it is possible to operate in one protocol only or does it operate in all the protocols at the same time ?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
90 Posts
QUOTE (dbclass50 @ 4 May 2007, 17:05) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>Nice report MMaD & thanks for posting it.

I have been thinking seriously about this beast but am wondering if it is possible to operate in one protocol only or does it operate in all the protocols at the same time ?

My understanding is that it issues commands only using the protocols it needs to control the equipment you have selected to operate from it's internal database. If all of the configured / selected equipment in the ecos database is using the same protocol then it will be communicating only with that one protocol, If however you do have something in the database configured with motorola, for instance, and that piece of equipment is operational then there will be occasions that commands will be issued simultaneously in both.

As far as the posted review is concerned i would agree with every word of it, i am really really chuffed with mine. The comment about the lack of walkabout throttles is easily overcome, i have a roco lokmaus 2 which works perfectly well through the ecosniffer.

Have a great day

Mark
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
7,397 Posts
QUOTE (John Buckland @ 29 May 2007, 15:42) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>Sounds good. Is it fully compatible with mainstream loco and accessory decoders (eg Lenz)?
Completely. I use Lenz Gold as my standard decoder and it works and programmes pefectly. The only one that was a bit iffy was the QSI decoder which it could only read 87% of. Why I don't know. It worked ok though.
 
1 - 5 of 5 Posts
Top