QUOTE (Geoff Booth @ 1 Feb 2008, 16:49)
<{POST_SNAPBACK}>So why are Minitrix and Fleischmann both doing the BLS Re485 in 2008? It will be interesting to compare the quality and price.
Good question Geoff! There is a good answer though - the Minitrix model is a very clever offering: much cheaper model, endless livery potential as Fleischmann demonstrates, and although it compromises on some details this is the key difference:
Fleischmann SBB Re 482 @ ~£150
Minitrix SBB Re 482 @ ~£75
This applies to the BLS Cargo model too. The first issue by Fleischmann was a very limited special series, but the livery is very striking I think so popular with modellers hence it returns.
The models are actually really quite similar - there is an excellent thread with lots of direct comparison pictures on the Spur-N-Schweiz forum
here.
Quite close really, the main "drawbacks" of the Minitrix model are the roof conductors too red, pantographs not painted, underframe and wheel details not as good etc. but otherwise an excellent model - if the Fleischmann one didn't exist people would be highly delighted with it!! A touch of paint and these things can be corrected...also you can buy two Minitrix and double-head a heavy train for the cost of a single Fleischmann model.
I have a Fleischmann Re 482 of the SBB and have to say it one of the best models I have in all respects (exquisite is the word!) except the white LED headlights (easy to change), and I am thinking of getting the Minitrix one since if it goes second then it will be noticed less, not that it isn't a fine model itself! Here modellers have a real choice and I think that is excellent - perhaps Fleischmann will cut its prices to compete better...
...and hats off to Minitrix for the bold move!
QUOTE (Geoff Booth @ 1 Feb 2008, 16:49)
<{POST_SNAPBACK}>All we need now are the long awaited Hobbytrain double-decker SBB IC coaches and it will be an expensive year!!
Fingers crossed for 2009 delivery...