Model Railway Forum banner
1 - 7 of 7 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
1 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
I’ve recently retrieved by old train set from my parents house and being the tinkerer that he was, he did something to the train to enable it to run along a pice of track.

the picture shows 2 wires going nowhere. Can anyone help with how the wiring should look?

thanks
Alastair
Automotive tire Bumper Wheel Track Motor vehicle
 

·
In depth idiot
Joined
·
8,356 Posts
From appearance I think this must have started life as a three rail mechanism, (the plate from which the valve gear is hung bridges the driving wheels) which suggests to me that the wires are 'flying leads' to run the motor with no power collection from the rails. 'Quick and dirty' test, try a PP9 battery on the paired green and brown wires to see if that makes the motor run: green to one battery terminal, brown to the other.

Not being able to see what connections there are to the pick up skid (if present) or motor brushes, it is difficult to suggest anything further.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
76 Posts
It's unlikely that it was originally three rail, unless the body has been changed at some point, as the three rail version was the City of Liverpool and the two rail one the City of London. If I recall correctly, in the two rail version, one wire goes through the hole in the chassis block between the centre wheels to the wire pickup to the insulated wheels, and the other was screwed into the chassis block, which was live to the uninsulated wheels.

I'm afraid that the examples I have had their two rail pickup assemblies removed and replaced with three rail ones, so I can't go and take a body off one to check how the thing is wired up (and, if you're wondering why I didn't just buy a City of Liverpool in the first place, they are one of the Dublo rarities, and attract high prices; a City of London, by comparison, is relatively inexpensive).
 

·
In depth idiot
Joined
·
8,356 Posts
Side question out of curiousity. I only have an 8F 3 rail chassis to look at, (no motor or wiring) and similar to the Duchess, the steel plate at the front end which supports the all metal valve gear means there is a conduction path from coupled wheelface to wheelface - which is fine for 3 rail of course.

So to the question, for 2 rail where did H-D have insulation to prevent the side rods shorting out the rails on outside valve gear models? As far as I can see, on the wiper pick up side it would have to be every crankpin insulated from the wheel.

... I can't go and take a body off one to check how the thing is wired up...
Same here, but that pair of green and brown wires loosely twisted are not original H-D construction in my opinion, thus my guess that the chassis is modified to allow operation on unpowered track, supplying power via that pair of wires. And if it is modified, then it's anyone's guess what has been done. We won't know more until Alastair posts.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
76 Posts
Side question out of curiousity. I only have an 8F 3 rail chassis to look at, (no motor or wiring) and similar to the Duchess, the steel plate at the front end which supports the all metal valve gear means there is a conduction path from coupled wheelface to wheelface - which is fine for 3 rail of course.
I must confess that I wondered the same thing when I looked at it, but I have checked the Dublo Servicing Leaflet for these locomotives and it shows that the City of London has the same valve gear assembly plate as the City of Liverpool, part number 20764. Your thought of the difference maybe having something to do with the coupling rod pins may well be right, as the coupling rod pins on the insulated wheels had a different part number (20689) from the coupling rod pins on the uninsulated side, which had the same part number as all of the coupling rod pins on the three rail version (7741).

Below is a photograph of my City of London which is, wiring aside, identical to the one in the photograph in first post in this thread.

Train Wheel Engineering Gas Rolling


that pair of green and brown wires loosely twisted are not original H-D construction in my opinion
The green and brown wires are definitely not original, but I suspect that only the person who fitted them would be able to explain why they were there. Unfortunately for the purposes of this thread, I have converted my locomotive to three rail by fitting an HD three rail pickup assembly (I also fitted metal wheels to the leading bogie), so it's not much use for sorting out the wiring question.
 

·
In depth idiot
Joined
·
8,356 Posts
Below is a photograph of my City of London which is, wiring aside, identical to the one in the photograph in first post in this thread...
That's helpfully clear. (For Alastair, the blue wire is the insulated feed from 3rd rail skid or 2 rail pick up wipers, yellow insulated component in line to the insulated brush is a choke, and the small grey capacitor bridges the insulated supply and the live to rail chassis block via the terminal just forward.)
... Your thought of the difference maybe having something to do with the coupling rod pins may well be right, as the coupling rod pins on the insulated wheels had a different part number (20689) from the coupling rod pins on the uninsulated side, which had the same part number as all of the coupling rod pins on the three rail version (7741)...
Thanks for confirming that. Couldn't see any more economical way of achieving this given the constructional plan.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
76 Posts
All right then, here's the answer to the insulation question. I had a two rail Dublo A4 chassis I converted to three rail some time ago, but it wasn't a very good runner as it appears that a previous owner took the wheels off at some point and then refitted them somewhat inaccurately (I guess that he also did the job with a screwdriver and bent some bits in the process). As I have since got hold of a rolling chassis for a three rail A4 and swapped all the bits over, I now have no use for the two rail chassis, so I decided to pull out one of the coupling rod pins on the insulated side. It turns out that the holes for the coupling rod pins in the insulated wheels are about double the size of the ones on the uninsulated side. There is a plastic (or nylon?) sleeve in each hole and the sleeve is shouldered where it touches the coupling rod, so that neither the pin nor the coupling rod are in electrical contact with the wheel. Hopefully it can be seen in the photograph below, although my digital camera isn't much good for close ups, so the photo isn't as sharp as I would like.

Wheel Tire Bicycle tire Bicycle Light
 
1 - 7 of 7 Posts
Top