Model Railway Forum banner

Model Rail issue 107 August 2007 Hornby Digital

11329 Views 117 Replies 27 Participants Last post by  Doug
When you get the new issue of Model Rail - have a good read of Model Rail extra - the two extensive comments one by an official of NMRA ( Didrik Voss ) and Richard Johnson of DCCUK about Hornby digital are well worth the price of the mag . I was surprised to read the critique in Model Rail who to their credit have published it - well done Model Rail and Chris Leigh I salute you for not favouring advertisers..

It would appear that all our comments re: Hornby Digital have been justified.
Status
Not open for further replies.
1 - 1 of 118 Posts
At the end of the day all any modeller wants is a system which work's ok, the same as all the other dcc systems, the main problem with Hornby dcc is that it has been made to a price and it show's.
When the select was launched, last year I e mailed Gaugemaster asking about the problems with the Hornby decoder I had a phone call back and given a explanation what the problems were even then, last november, the waveforms given out by the Select had been checked by Gaugemaster , I was also offered the chance to return the prodigy back and it would be rechipped so i could use a Hornby decoder, as the prodigy had worked ok with all the other decoder's 21 in total I decided not to bother.
Gary your defence of Hornby has to be admired, but at the end of the day Hornby WILL HAVE TO CHANGE OR LOOSE SALES I AND I SUSPECT MANY OTHERS WILL NOT BUY A HORNBY LOCO FITTED WITH THAT DECODER.
Richard Johnstone has no axe to grind about Hornby and is a expert in his field, I know who i would listen to.
See less See more
1 - 1 of 118 Posts
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top